Wednesday, June 8, 2016

Book Review: With Malice by Eileen Cook

With Malice by Eileen Cook book cover and review
With Malice reveals an exciting and interesting premise, but the resolution just fizzled.

Jill wakes up in a hospital severely injured, and her first concern is will she still be able to make her planned trip to Italy. She is shocked to find out that her injury occurred in Italy, and that she has lost the memories from the last several weeks of her life.

She also wants to see her lifelong best friend, Simone, and soon finds out that they were both in a car accident. Jill was driving and Simone was killed. Her father had Jill jetted back to the US presumably to receive the best medical care, but also to receive the best legal advice. It seems the Italian authorities think the car crash may not have been an accident.

Jill spends the rest of her time in the hospital and then in rehab trying to figure out what happened. The reader gets police interviews and blog posts from those that were witnesses or those that were close to the girls. While the interviews reveal some details, the truth still isn't clear to the reader.

Jill is convinced there's no way she would have harmed Simone, no matter what they were arguing about. Even if it was about the Italian tour guide that Jill had a huge crush on and Simone tried to steal. But as the truth comes out...

Well, I'm not going to say any more. The ending is ambiguous and the expected twist really didn't materialize. There is an interesting revelation that any savvy reader could have predicted. With Malice  has been compared to We Were Liars but doesn't pack nearly the punch. I didn't experience any attachment to Jill. Maybe I'm not supposed to. I didn't dislike her, but I didn't really feel myself pulling for her.

The writing is easy, and With Malice is a quick read. The story is intriguing, and maybe teens will be more shocked at the revelations than I was.

Published by HMH BFYR, June 7, 2016
eARC obtained from Edelweiss
320 pages

Rating: 3/5

Back to Annette's Book Spot Homepage Copyright © 2016 Annette's Book Spot. All Rights Reserved


  1. I usually love books like these. Too bad it fizzled. Sounds like a good premise with lots of promise. Bummer.

  2. From your description I was beginning to think the book was a good one and then decided it isn't. A mystery with no resolution or punch. Hmm. I think I'll skip it. Thanks for visiting my blog and for participating in my little quirky questionnaire.

  3. I really enjoyed this story. Trying to piece together the pieces as Jill discovers a little more every day. The interviews and investigation updates were just enough to give me that outside look into things and keep tons of doubt in my mind. Almost a who-done-it, but with such a twist!

    Look at Best Aluminum Boats visit site


Thanks for visiting! I LOVE comments! I've received several awards and because of the time involved, I now must make this an award free blog.


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...