Wednesday, June 27, 2012

Book Review: Monument 14, by Emmy Laybourne

Monument 14 is a survival story with a scenario so realistic that one can't help feel the discomfort that these young characters feel.

First there's hail - not just any hail, but large, unrelenting hail. The school bus driver drives into a superstore (think: Wal Mart) to save the kids on her bus, as well as the kids on the high school bus that crashed in the parking lot. Then, there's a horrible earth quake. Then, a toxic black cloud. These kids just can't get a break.

At first there is the scramble to survive, to get the store sealed off from the toxic air and to provide basic needs. Also, since these are 14 kids of various ages and backgrounds, there's conflict. The personalities of these teens are realistic, and therefore the natural tendencies for some to be leaders, followers, bullies, and parents ring true.

The many decisions that need to be made are handled well sometimes, and have devastating consequences at other times. I felt really uncomfortable while reading this -- it hits too close to home, since this scenario isn't really that far-fetched. The fact that kids are forbidden to drive to school because of a gas shortage and the references to "minitabs" and "bigtabs" that are hooked into a network (not that far off...) give a "near future" perspective.

Laybourne builds tension in Monument 14 that never relents. There's always a new challenge, and unfortunately, there isn't any resolution. Another one of those "half books" that just ends. A big decision is made, and that's it. Very frustrating. Somewhere the literary structure of writing (exposition, rising action, climax, falling action, denouement) has just been lost in a lot of current books, and I guess I'm just too traditional to enjoy this new "series mania." *steps off soapbox*

Teens will like Monument 14. It's a classic survival story of teens on their own, being resourceful as well as frightened, but stepping up and growing as necessary. The realistic situation provides much food for thought.

Published by Feiwel & Friends, June 5, 2012
ARC obtained from Library Media Connection
294 pages

Rating: 3.5/5

Back to Annette's Book Spot Homepage Copyright © 2012 Annette's Book Spot. All Rights Reserved


  1. Ugh, I was wanting to read this one, but I hate when things aren't resolved. If it's a series, I will just wait until all the books are out. I wish that even series books had a complete story arch. It sucks when they don't and you have to wait for the next book and forget everything from the previous book.

  2. I have this, but haven't gotten to it yet. Your review makes me think I might wait because I get so frustrated when series books cut off without at least some satisfaction... Great review!

    Karis @ YA Litwit

  3. I guess I know what you mean... sometimes series can be frustration especially when you have to wait forever for the next book. I think each book should have their own little story arc with an ending, so that you are in a good place when finishing the book, but still eager to pick of the next ...

  4. Great review!!! To tell you the truth I am not really too anxious to read this one but the fact that you liked it definitely makes me want to reconsider!!!! Although I am not a huge fan of action and impulsive characters, the concept definitely sounds unique!

    grace (Alaska Bear Hunting)


Thanks for visiting! I LOVE comments! I've received several awards and because of the time involved, I now must make this an award free blog.


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...